'08 Elantra #1 in New Consumer Reports

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rev. Tom Wenndt
  • Start date Start date
R

Rev. Tom Wenndt

For whatever you think of this magazine, they have just this week released
their July issue. In it, they test several small cars, including the
Elantra SE.

Not only was it tops amongst the tested cars, including the Toyota Corolla,
which got 32 mpg average (the Hyundai got 27), but was once again
established as THE top compact car.

Considering the 'blind spot' they have always had (up until now anyway)
towards Toyota, it is good to see Hyundai getting their due.

If it isn't already, it should be on the news-stands this week.
 
Rev. Tom Wenndt said:
For whatever you think of this magazine, they have just this week released
their July issue. In it, they test several small cars, including the
Elantra SE.

Not only was it tops amongst the tested cars, including the Toyota Corolla,
which got 32 mpg average (the Hyundai got 27), but was once again
established as THE top compact car.

Considering the 'blind spot' they have always had (up until now anyway)
towards Toyota, it is good to see Hyundai getting their due.

If it isn't already, it should be on the news-stands this week.
Click to expand...

Yes, I just read that issue. Now if Hyundai could just get their
engines refined to the level of Toyota (or GM for that matter) and get
their mileage competitive, they would be a real force in the auto world.

Regarding the GM comment, I flew to Atlanta recently to drive back my
mother-in-law's Buick Century (I think it is a 2000). It has a V-6 (I
think 3.1L, but I'm not 100% sure on that). I cruised at a steady 70
MPH nearly the entire 840 miles and achieved 33 MPG on both tanks of
gas! I went over 500 miles on the first tank and I think it is a 17
gallon tank. This is better mileage than my 4 cylinder Sonata can
achieve in similar circumstances. It gets maybe 31-32 at 70, but will
get 33 if I run at 60 or so.

Other than the design issues (hyper sensitive throttle, "no feel"
clutch, weak AC, etc.) that we've hashed over many times here in the
past, the dismal MPG is the main ongoing niggle with my Sonata. I was
hoping to average 30+ MPG given that my driving is mostly highway, and
the EPA ratings were 24/34. I'm running at 29.25 for the nearly 40,000
miles now on the car. This isn't terrible, but running right at the EPA
mid-point isn't very good for my driving regime.

Now, before you launch into the "EPA numbers aren't realistic" speech,
I'm well aware of that, but for MY driving I've acheived the highway MPG
or within 1 MPG of it on every vehicle I've owned for the last 15 years
.... except the Sonata. My pickup was a 14/18 rating as I recall, I I
get 17-18 pretty consistently driving back and forth to work. Same with
my minivans and the Plymouth Acclaim and Jeep Comanche before them. The
Sonata is the first vehicle I've had that runs only midway up the EPA
range in driving that is mostly highway.

So, Hyundai, hire a few former GM or Toyota engineers and get your
engines up to snuff before I need another car! :-)

Matt
 
Matt Whiting said:
Yes, I just read that issue. Now if Hyundai could just get their engines
refined to the level of Toyota (or GM for that matter) and get their
mileage competitive, they would be a real force in the auto world.

Regarding the GM comment, I flew to Atlanta recently to drive back my
mother-in-law's Buick Century (I think it is a 2000). It has a V-6 (I
think 3.1L, but I'm not 100% sure on that). I cruised at a steady 70 MPH
nearly the entire 840 miles and achieved 33 MPG on both tanks of gas! I
went over 500 miles on the first tank and I think it is a 17 gallon tank.
This is better mileage than my 4 cylinder Sonata can achieve in similar
circumstances. It gets maybe 31-32 at 70, but will get 33 if I run at 60
or so.
Click to expand...

I rented the "Big" Cadillac a few years back for a 2200 mile trip. I don't
remember exactly but it was almost unbelievable the MPG the car achieved. I
averaged around 80 mph and something like 28 mpg.
 
Yes, I just read that issue. Now if Hyundai could just get their
engines refined to the level of Toyota (or GM for that matter) and get
their mileage competitive, they would be a real force in the auto world.
Click to expand...

I think that you will find that they are already there, certainly at
the level of GM.

The present Santa Fe and Vera Cruz (also the same engines as in the
Sonata and Azera, resp. I believe) are very refined according to CR
reviews and personal experience. AAMOF, CR went so far as to say that
despite the better fuel efficiency of the Corolla, Elantra was more
refined.

I will concede that the Hyundai 4 bangers are not paradigms of fuel
efficiency compared to Toyota (IMO the class leader) and even Honda.

On the other hand, the Santa Fe's fuel economy
(http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24984.shtml) is on par with
Toyota (http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24629.shtml) and Chevy
(http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24573.shtml) and better than
the Honda (http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24609.shtml) in
SUVs with similar size engine.

The V6s are just fine. Now on to the genesis and the V8's.
 
Rob said:
I rented the "Big" Cadillac a few years back for a 2200 mile trip. I
don't remember exactly but it was almost unbelievable the MPG the car
achieved. I averaged around 80 mph and something like 28 mpg.
Click to expand...

Yes, I agree. I rented a Buick Park Avenue a few years ago for a trip
to Boston. I was in a hurry and ran 70-80 MPH that trip and got 30 MPG
with that fairly large car. I was amazed.

Matt
 
Wayne said:
I think that you will find that they are already there, certainly at
the level of GM.

The present Santa Fe and Vera Cruz (also the same engines as in the
Sonata and Azera, resp. I believe) are very refined according to CR
reviews and personal experience. AAMOF, CR went so far as to say that
despite the better fuel efficiency of the Corolla, Elantra was more
refined.

I will concede that the Hyundai 4 bangers are not paradigms of fuel
efficiency compared to Toyota (IMO the class leader) and even Honda.

On the other hand, the Santa Fe's fuel economy
(http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24984.shtml) is on par with
Toyota (http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24629.shtml) and Chevy
(http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24573.shtml) and better than
the Honda (http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/noframes/24609.shtml) in
SUVs with similar size engine.

The V6s are just fine. Now on to the genesis and the V8's.
Click to expand...

CR bases "refinement" apparently only on levels of vibration and sound.
I'm using the term in a much broader sense and also specifically
qualified with respect to fuel efficiency. I don't think Hyundai yet
makes an engine that is truly at the world class level of GM and Toyota,
but maybe some of those you list above are there or close. My Sonata
2.4L isn't quite there. It is competitive in power, smoothness and
noise levels, but falls short in fuel efficiency.

Matt
 
Matt Whiting said:
CR bases "refinement" apparently only on levels of vibration and sound.
I'm using the term in a much broader sense and also specifically qualified
with respect to fuel efficiency. I don't think Hyundai yet makes an
engine that is truly at the world class level of GM and Toyota, but maybe
some of those you list above are there or close. My Sonata 2.4L isn't
quite there. It is competitive in power, smoothness and noise levels, but
falls short in fuel efficiency.

Matt
Click to expand...

I have the V-6. Mileage is about the same as my LeSabre. OK, but not great.
Performance is better though.
 
I recently rented a Hertz 2009 Sonata GLS for a week, and put
approximately 1,500 miles on the car. In my business travels, it
seems that Hertz rents quite a few Hyundais - four Sonata's and one
Azera in the last seven rentals! The new Sonata was a significant
improvement over the 2007 and 2008 Sonata GLS's I've rented. Other
than the obvious improvement in the center stack and in other areas,
there are two substantial mechanical improvements I noticed with the
2009: 1). The rear suspension - in every Sonata GLS I've previously
rented, the rear suspension seemed to be a bit soft and tended to
bottom out with either a full load of people or a fair amount of
weight in the trunk. This is no longer the case with the 2009. Not
only did I find the rear suspension much, much better in this regard,
the car simply drove and tracked more accurately, and 2). The 2.4L
DOHC engine and new 5-speed automatic combination - a much better
combination for highway driving. The transmission is almost seamless
in it's gear changes, and most importantly, the fuel mileage has
improved. When checking highway fuel mileage (the old-fashioned way,
along with the use of the trip computer), the mileage was 34.5MPG, and
this was at a typical average of 70+MPH. The overall mileage after
the 1,500 mile trip with a combination of 75% highway and 25% city was
30.1MPG. This is very close to the exact numbers I received with my
last Toyota Camry rental about 8 months ago. The new 5-speed
automatic has improved the drivetrain on the 4-cylinder immensely.
And, this car only had 1,100 miles on the odometer when I rented it,
so if it's similar to other Hyundai's I've owned, the fuel economy may
actually improve over time.
 
Don Allen said:
I recently rented a Hertz 2009 Sonata GLS for a week, and put
approximately 1,500 miles on the car. In my business travels, it
seems that Hertz rents quite a few Hyundais - four Sonata's and one
Azera in the last seven rentals! The new Sonata was a significant
improvement over the 2007 and 2008 Sonata GLS's I've rented.
Click to expand...

<................ snip ................>

Good write up Don. Thanks.
 
Don Allen said:
I recently rented a Hertz 2009 Sonata GLS for a week, and put
approximately 1,500 miles on the car. In my business travels, it
seems that Hertz rents quite a few Hyundais - four Sonata's and one
Azera in the last seven rentals! The new Sonata was a significant
improvement over the 2007 and 2008 Sonata GLS's I've rented.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the good info. What do you think of the Azera?
 
Thanks for the good info. What do you think of the Azera?
Click to expand...

We had an Hertz Azera Limited in March for a business trip to
Charlotte, NC (from central IL). My wife and I made it a bit of a
vacation, and stopped overnight near Sevierville, TN. We were both
very impressed by the Azera. Very comfortable, yet good suspension
control, and an excellent engine. The overall fuel economy for the
trip was in the 24 to 25MPG range with highway at 28.5MPG. It was a
very nice car, and we actually hated returning it back to Hertz! In
my opinion, this is one excellent automotive value.
 
Back
Top