Elantra GT grinding gears

klaron

Usenet Archive
Joined
Apr 19, 2004
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Anyone heard of this?

My wife's new 04 Elantra GT grinds everytime you go from 1st to 2nd gear. The only way it won't is if, when going from 1st to 2nd, pause in neutral for about a half-second, then it will go into 2nd gear just fine.

It doesn't do this when going into 2nd from any other gear.

We are waiting to hear back from our Hyundai dealer to bring the car in. I hope it is something easy and simple to fix as I have been very, very happy with the car overall!
 
klaron said:
Anyone heard of this?

My wife's new 04 Elantra GT grinds everytime you go from 1st to 2nd gear. The only way it won't is if, when going from 1st to 2nd, pause in neutral for about a half-second, then it will go into 2nd gear just fine.

It doesn't do this when going into 2nd from any other gear.

We are waiting to hear back from our Hyundai dealer to bring the car in. I hope it is something easy and simple to fix as I have been very, very happy with the car overall!

My 03 GT does the exact same thing. I just live with it....

Regards,

Neil
 
klaron said:
My wife's new 04 Elantra GT grinds everytime you go from 1st to 2nd gear. The only way it won't is if, when going from 1st to 2nd, pause in neutral for about a half-second, then it will go into 2nd gear just fine.
It doesn't do this when going into 2nd from any other gear.

[Disclaimer: I am making an educated guess on this -- I could be entirely wrong]

Sounds like it could be an issue with the synchros for 2nd gear. The synchros make sure that your transmission is spinning at the same speed as your wheels when you push the stick into a particular gear. They're kind of like the clutch plate between the wheels and the transmission, whereas your regular clutch is the one that goes between the engine and your transmission.

That is the resistance you feel when you try to enter a very low gear when you're going very fast. The synchro has to slip a whole lot to get your transmission spinning at the very high speed needed to match up to the speed of your wheels, since it's in such a low gear.

If you try to force the shifter into a particular gear when your clutch is engaged, your synchros will simply wear themselves out trying to match the transmission's speed to the wheels' speed, since there is no chance in hell that those measly synchros can slow the transmission when the transmission has the power of the whole engine backing it.

Anyway, the synchro could be unable to get a good grip on your transmission to slow it down to the speed necessary to shift into 2nd, and it's letting you shift anyway, even though the transmission and the wheels are going at different speeds. Hence, the grinding. They may, though, be able to grip in the opposite direction (that is, speeding up the transmission).

Anyone care to offer their thoughts on my theory?

Moshe
 
I suppose it's possible. I currently have one of these apart now. The car has really low mileage like 5k mi or something. If this is a frequent problem, there may be a redesign or a tsb issued in the near future.

In the car I'm working on, gear clashed on any shift into 2nd gear after driving for more than a few minutes. Upon disassembling the trans, fourth gear looked as damaged as second. I'm hoping this turns into a few rogue cases, but the amount of replies scares me.
 
Yes, mine does the exact same thing. Sounds pretty common among Hyundai. I am trying to get mine fixed but of course the dealership is reluctant.

I wish I hadn't bought it!
 
Alberta said:
Yes, mine does the exact same thing. Sounds pretty common among Hyundai. I am trying to get mine fixed but of course the dealership is reluctant.

I wish I hadn't bought it!

My Accent did the same thing, but other than being mildly annoying, it never caused a problem. That was a Mitsubishi transmission, BTW. I don't know if that's the case with the '04 Elantra or not. So far, I've had no trouble with mine grinding at all, before or after installing a short shifter.
 
Brian said:
My Accent did the same thing, but other than being mildly annoying, it never caused a problem. That was a Mitsubishi transmission, BTW. I don't know if that's the case with the '04 Elantra or not. So far, I've had no trouble with mine grinding at all, before or after installing a short shifter.

We are bringing the car in today to have the dealership fix the problem. The car didn't do the grinding initially, it developed however, within the first 1000 miles. I'll post here how things go with the service folks.
 
In the car I'm working on, gear clashed on any shift into 2nd gear after
driving for more than a few minutes. Upon disassembling the trans, fourth gear looked as damaged as second. I'm hoping this turns into a few rogue cases, but the amount of replies scares me.

This really sounds like a clutch not releasing all the way problem rather than a transaxle problem. Cold gear oil is thicker and is better able to match the speeds of the input/output shafts, so no clash when cold. Once it begins to warm up the oil thins a little bit and then the issue with the clutch not releasing starts to come into play. Of course if the owner continued to drive it with the gears grinding I could see how things could get torn up internally in short order.

Could even be wrong lubricant. I had a dealer put ATF in my sephia 5spd box one time. I could see doing that if I lived in the antartic but in arizona you need the 85w90 legit gear oil.

Chris
 
Back
Top